Mr. Baldy's Family Restaurant

Food is always good for a good price. Been coming here for a long time on family vacations. I will say I really miss the old look. It used to be very colorful and fun inside. Used to have a large mural painted on the wall. Now everything is gray and bland inside. Food is still great Just miss the colorful unique atmosphere that made the restaurant come to life.

Went for the Chicken and Dumplings. They had sold out earlier in the day. Waitress gave us the option to leave but we decided to stay. The tables are very cute with personal messages. I asked what the waitress would recommend. She suggested the hot roast beef sandwich. 🥪 OMG! I’ve never seen anything like it. Maybe it’s a regional thing? Two slices of bread with a steak um. Mashed potatoes were powdered along with the gravy. It took everything out of me to eat it…. On a good note the waitress was very good and the side salad was good!

Mister Baldy’s (We’re not going back!) My wife and I have vacationed on Chincoteague every September for quite a few years, and we have never tried Mister Baldy’s. We decided to give it a try this time and I can say without hesitation that our first time will most definitely be the last time!w The deal breaker for me was the soft shell crab sandwich. Talk about boring and plain… The sandwich was a single, sad looking soft crab sandwiched between two halves of a bun. NO lettuce, onion, tomato, pickle, tarter sauce. NOTHING but one crab between two pieces of bread. I should mention that the cook managed to use a fairly large toothpick to hold the whole thing together, but believe me, no toothpick was required. A three year old’s hands are big enough to hold this piece of work together! The s

We had a great lunch at Mr Baldy’s while on vacation in Chincoteague this past week. The crab soup was excellent! The sandwiches were really good and the cheese sticks were tasty as well. If you’re looking for a good meal, stop in there. We’ll definitely go back!

Enjoyed our meal here. Server lady was nice. Ordered the crab cake sandwich and it was really good. I liked their fries. Got the crab soup which was also really good. My toddler loved it. Not too salty. It says it’s a family restaurant but they don’t have changing tables in the restroom…. The restroom was clean at least.