Mister Whippy

Loved our soft serve at Mister Whippy! They also have a nice gelato selection and earlier in the day the coffee shop and bakery is open as well. The porch seating was nice and breezy in the evening! They also have a drive through.

Wonderful staff that were super friendly and helpful. They dont take card so bring cash or use their ATM. Come for donuts and ice cream. Worth a trip.

We stopped for ice cream at the very begining of the season so staffing was not fully in place. It took a few minutes, and asking another guest, where to order the ice cream. The store is broken into a few different windows: one for coffee and donuts, once for ice cream and it appears another for a gift shop. We had a bit of a wait for our order to be taken but the staff were doing their best to take care of everyone in the store and those at the drive through. The prices were reasonable and the ice cream was great. I'm not sure if its like this through the summer but when we were there they only took cash for payment.

Another favorite place to stop on the Island. Love the coffee! Everyone loves the ice cream! Incidentally, it’s named after the Whippy’s ice cream truck they have outside. The truck is from the UK.

The Brownie Delight was an absolute 10/10. The soft serve vanilla ice cream is TO DIE FOR. So creamy, amazing flavor. The brownie was incredible. So reasonably priced compared to the other creamery’s around ($6). Love this place. It only accepts cash but there’s an ATM in the creamery.