Tisha's Fine Dining

Tisha’s is the kind of small, cozy spot that immediately makes you feel at ease. The intimate setting makes it perfect for a date night or a quiet, reflective meal where the ambiance adds to the experience It’s BYOB, which made the evening even more special — I brought a bottle of Bollinger La Grande Année to mark the occasion, and it paired beautifully with the meal. I started with the PEI mussels in a Thai coconut curry. The broth was rich, fragrant, and deeply satisfying. I skipped the bread but made good use my spoon to include a good helping of sauce along with delicious mussels. For my entrée, I had the Atlantic salmon topped with jumbo shrimp, served over mashed potatoes with asparagus. Everything was well-balanced, flavorful, and thoughtfully prepared. Dessert was bread pudding

Our group of 4 has a fantastic dinner here. Space is a little on the tight side but the service and food were top notch. Everyone's meal was excellent. The filet, pork chop and short ribs were served hot and tasted amazing. All 4 meals were perfect. Then to top it off, everyone had a different dessert and everyone loved their dessert which I often find can often be disappointing, but not here. All 4 of us talked about how good the dinner was on the ride home. We dined on a slow mid week early December night and the place filled up. I'd recommend making a reservation.

Came here for dinner for my cousins bachelorette weekend. Love a great BYOB and this place came highly reccomended. Service was great and food was phenomenal. Would definitely go back if I go back to that area. The calamari was EXCELLENT, burrito a peach salad was ok, the peaches weren't ripe so that was a little underwhelming. The Halibut that had on special was incredible, so fresh and cooked perfectly. The filet was delicious but the peppercorn(in my opinion) was a little too much to my liking. The seafood risotto was very flavorful and cooked perfectly as well. The gnocchi was great too.

This restaurant deserves five stars all around! The service was great. The atmosphere is quaint. But the food is definitely spot on. Everything from the appetizers right through to the dessert was amazing. No complaints had by anyone at the dinner table, and we went with a big group. I would definitely recommend if you’re looking for a more luxurious meal.

We have been here multiple times over the past few years, and the food and service are always above and beyond. Danny has been our server the last two times we have been here and he remembered us and even where we sat the last time. We came today to celebrate our one year wedding anniversary while in Cape May. We are from Pittsburgh so we are only here once a year or so. We always make a point to stop here for dinner while vacationing in CM. The food is always delicious but the service is more so what keeps us coming back. I can’t speak highly enough about this restaurant. If you’re looking for fine dining while in Cape May, this is the place to go. Thank you, Tisha’s, for always making us feel special!