Peace Pie

I tried the chocolate peanut butter cookie dough and it was delicious. I would definitely return and recommend stopping! Update: it’s December and 38 degrees and I stopped here for a second time today. It’s delicious. I tried the Elvis the second time.

Part of me wishes this place were closer, but the other half of me is glad that it's not. I could eat this three times a day. Great little shop, I love the little window setup. Great staff and amazing ice cream flavors.

My recent visit to Peace Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches was unfortunately disappointing. The pre-made sandwiches took quite a while to unfreeze, and the cookie part was hard until it thawed. As a first-time customer, I felt the staff wasn’t very friendly, which added to the less-than-pleasant experience. Additionally, there was no proper seating available, making it difficult to enjoy the ice cream on-site. I even had to walk across the street to find a trash can, which seems like an oversight for a food establishment. At the very least, they should provide trash disposal options for their customers. Overall, I was underwhelmed and unlikely to return.

Peace Pie in Cape May is a delightful treasure for anyone with a sweet tooth. My wife and I tried their Peanut Butter Brownie ice cream sandwich, and it was absolutely delicious. While I prefer a softer cookie, the crunchy ones they use held up well and still tasted fantastic. I was impressed by the huge range of flavor options they offer. It’s clear they’ve put thought into creativity and quality. The shop is charming, the service was friendly and efficient, and the overall vibe fits perfectly within the Cape May dessert scene. If you’re in Cape May and looking for a memorable treat, Peace Pie deserves a stop. We’ll certainly be back to try even more of their flavors.

The ice cream sandwich was decent but not for the price. It was $8 and they don’t have it advertised anywhere. It was also very hard to eat as the ice cream is pretty frozen. It was good but not worth the hype.