Papa's Pizza Oven

I love the Stinger pizza here, but the service really hurts the experience. I ordered a large stinger and 20 wings (10 hot, 10 medium garlic parm). I checked the food after leaving and I had to go back because all the wings were garlic parm. The employee took the box back and brought it back with the other wings in it. When I got home I tried both wings and then realized that I was given hot bbq sauce and not buffalo. Not only that, the employee removed 12 wings instead of 10 and only gave me 9 of the hot bbq sauce! So I’m 3 wings short, and it’s the wrong sauce TWICE! Not cool. I’m regretting suggesting this place to my friends, definitely won’t be returning for wings again.

I really enjoyed this place when it was new but the last 2 times at the Lancaster location have been terrible at lunch time. The first issue that I had was completely raw dough, the issue today was that I ordered 2 slices with regular sauce, and what I received was a overly sweet sauce that had a ketchup taste to it and almost the same consistency and the cheese hadn’t even melted completely. I hate leaving bad reviews but for something as simple as slices you wouldn’t think to worry about it

Great tastings pizza and wings at an affordable price! The pizza is crisp and not greasy with lots of cheese, great sauce ( we like the regular style not sweet) and crisp pepperoni. We like that it is cut with different size slices actually! Wings and also crisp and delicious! Highly recommend

As a native Long Islander, I am very particular about my pizza. I’ve never been a huge fan of Buffalo-style pizza…that was until I found Papa’s Pizza Oven. Finding this family-owned pizza place was like a breath of fresh air in a sea of unfortunate pizza experiences i’ve had in Buffalo. The first time I walked into Papa’s, I was adorably greeted by the owner’s 9 year old son. It’s no question where he gets his charisma from—the owner welcomed me with a kindness that made me feel right at home. This place is OUTSTANDING. Hands down the best pizza in all of Buffalo. Their sweet sauce is unlike anything i’ve ever had before—absolutely delicious!! After my first visit to Papa’s, I found myself going back a few short days later, unable to shake the thought of their savory slices. Now onto the

The food is decent, but the service and building is terrible. I live 1.7 miles from the location. I’ve ordered from the Lake Ave location 3 times. Each time, I’ve arrived at the pick up time and had to wait between 15 - 30 mins for my order to be completed. First time, was in the middle of the week, nobody else was in there. They threw my pizza in as I walked in. Second time, pizza was ready but the wings were still being cooked. Pizza was not hot by the time I got home. Third time, I walked in to see my pizzas already sitting ready to go, but the wings and fried dough were still being cooked. By the time they finished, my pizza was cold and somehow the wings were also cold by the time I got home. Each time there is a different excuse. We’re training new staff, we’re down a fryer, we’re d