Frosty's Ice Cream

A cute little ice cream spot that was a gas station way back when on Broadway in Lancaster! Been going since it opened in the early 2000's because I lived down the street I took my grandson then now we went with his girlfriend and he is almost 25 years old! I had a baby coneof blueberry cheesecake ice cream was delicious plenty of cheesecake and blueberry! My grandson had warm brownie Sunday with whipped cream and chocolate sauce was plenty and every part of it was delicious! His girlfriend had a baby strawberry daiquiri was very good and just enough . The staff was friendly and helpful to our questions! Even a couple of wooden trains for the kids to play in. Great for all ages

Wish we had decided to stop at this shop sooner. It has become one of our favorite places to get icecream. The portions are very generous.

Step into a Lancaster tradition at Frosty's, a long-time local favorite that consistently earns high praise. You can't miss their distinctive building right on Broadway, complete with a convenient play area in front for children. Ordering is a seamless experience: just approach the window to select from a vast array of ice creams, shakes, and other unique specialties, then collect your delicious treat at the opposing window. One of the best surprises? Their legendary portion sizes – expect your order to be at least a size larger than what you'd typically receive elsewhere. Though their prices are in line with other local spots, Frosty's truly excels in delivering unparalleled quality, unique options, and exceptional value. .

Got the ice cream nachos 1000/10 i highly recommend this location! It was such a cute ice cream stand aswell with a cool waiting area especially if you have children ! Service was immaculate and the employees were all so sweet and accommodating! Also this location is cash only but they have an ATM!

The ice cream is very good, the price is more then fair & the amount of ice cream they pile into a cone is obscene! But...the place is really run down. There are several wooden playground vehicles made for kids to play on that have rot & broken pieces, exposed nails & screws sticking from loose boards. Standing water & algae in buckets on the property. I know this is a historic building & not much can be done to it but the property is in need of a good power wash & overhaul.