Frisbie’s Dairy Barn Homemade Ice Cream

7.4.25 this is my 3rd visit at this location (after moving from the Bloomfield location) and at 1st I thought this spot on Day Hill Rd was odd, but I've gotten used to it. There's lots of parking, tables to enjoy your treats, there are sidewalks for walks, there's a gas station and convenience store so you can run errands and get a treat. The ice cream is friggin amazing. I've had the red raspberry chocolate, mouse tracks, and the peanut butter, and strawberry. Yum. Yum. Yum. And although I don't get toppings, there are many of those to choose from too. 1 scoop of deliciousness makes any day better!

Me and my mother just went to frisbees in Bloomfield and they open at five so we were there early ish but when they were ment to open, nobody was in the building at all. We stayed there until 5:15 waiting for someone to get there but they didn't so we left. My advice is If you plan on running a small business, make sure people are there to open it when it's meant to open. For context, I've had good ice cream there around three times but that was almost an hour after they were "open" every time. Honestly sad I had to write this but we shouldn't have to wait for ice cream when your ment to be open.

We went for a quick ice cream and a one scoop, that was not very generous when comparing to others in the area, was $7.00! My ice cream was not even solid and barely cold. Definitely some inconsistencies with this place. The ice cream is very good but I'm not sure it's worth it anymore. I can get a giant sundae at another local stand and pay the same price for the one scoop here.

My family and I went lastnight. I give It 3 stars because they thought the ice cream was very good. I initially went for a milkshake, but quickly changed my mind when I saw there was only one size and it was $12 bucks. That’s a little pricey to me!

New Windsor location is awesome!! The ice cream is amazing - - so creamy and fresh. I usually order the cookie monster ice cream and the chocolate peanut butter but this time I tried the new seasonal flavor and it was sensational! I have never been a fan of waffle cones but frisbies changed my mind. They are crisp and I was told they are made daily in house. The staff was wonderful, friendly and efficient. I can't say enough good things about this place!!