Cape May Peanut Butter Co.

A decedent experience for you peanut butter fans. As soon as you walk into the store, your in the presence of sweetness. Peanut butter cookies the size of a man's fist draws your attention. This is followed by the wall of flavored peanut butter, jams, and food spreads. Coffee and hot chocolate are available to pair with your chosen treat. You're free to ask for sample tastings of any store products. Outside seating is available as well.

It's a store devoted to Peanut Butter, could there BE anything better than this? I think not! Service was fantastic, selection was great & even better, you can ask to sample pretty much anything. Prices were very reasonable, a lovely unexpected sweet treat store!

Really sweet employees. Got to sample everything I was interested in, a lot of variety as well. They have various options other than just straight peanut butter as well. Dog treats, peanut butter pie, chocolates and parfaits. I’d recommend the made to order peanut butter cannolis or the honey roasted peanut butter

When my husband started coming to the Cape May peanut butter company many years ago, the cookies were soft chewable very delicious. Anymore when we come there, the cookies are baked so much. They are rockhard and often burned on the bottom or so dark on the bottom that they have just been overcooked. The cookies do not seem to be good anymore. The peanut butter cookies with the big peanut butter Reesie’s on the top are so overcooked all the time they lack taste and they are so hard that it almost hurts your teeth biting into them. I don’t know who has been baking the cookies for the last year or so but they really need to cut the baking time. Too much less because peanut butter cookies are supposed to be soft and chewy and not rockhard. The ones my husband bought today the peanut butter cu

A must-stop for peanut butter lovers! Store was crazy busy when we were there mid week. While we didn’t see any samples, we did overhear customers commenting on must-haves, including the butterscotch peanut butter. The peanut butter square cookies we got were good and we enjoyed the beautiful backyard patio set up they have behind the store. Need to return for their butterscotch spread!