The Pizza Place - Hampton Bays

I agree with the negative reviews, this team there just doesn’t care, And they prefer only Latin Hispanic customers (all Spanish music & all TV stations are in Spanish). I Called today asked if they had any mushroom slices. The girl that answered the phone could not speak English. She replied order? I replied. I’m just asking to see if you have any mushroom slices available? She replied anything order? I hung up.. unable to communicate.

10:30 AM 7/17/2025 I walked into buy a slice of pizza, I waited and I waited and I waited and I waited at the counter where the guys were making pizza right there and nobody bought it to look up and say- hey can I help you out? So I walked right past them and I went to the bathroom which was very clean. Then I waited again at the pizza counter and again nobody bother to ask me if I need anything - so I left. It’s safe to say I will not be coming back here. It doesn’t matter how good or bad your pizza is. Customer service here on first impression sucked.

Follow up 02/08/2020: Note...Prior review over a year ago. Tonight I decided to go to this place after a movie. I sat down in the back part of the restaurant. I waited 15 minutes and not one person even acknowledged my presence. I sat quietly waiting fir the waitress to come to my table, meanwhile helping all the other tables that were there. Never a hello or a menu. I got up and sent to the front counter, told the cashier and left. No one there could care about my presence. Time to downgrade my prior rating to a 1. Thank you Pizza place for the eye opener! Today I stopped into the Pizza Place for a quick slice before the movie. The Pizza Place is redesign and and a new partnership of the prior John's Pizza. The place is very clean and their choices of foods from pizza

Every time you go here expect to pay something different and get used to overpaying. Counter person was so rude. Don’t waste your time with this low rent place there’s much better pizza in Hampton Bays

The Pizza Place is hands down my favorite pizza spot in the entire world! 🍕 I came all the way from Los Angeles just to eat here again, and it was absolutely worth it. Their Hawaiian pizza is the best I’ve ever had—perfect crust, delicious sauce, and the freshest toppings. Every bite reminded me why this place is truly special. If you’re anywhere nearby, you must stop in. You won’t regret it!