The Old Mill Inn

What a beautiful new place. First off, the old mill turned into restaurant is a great idea, tucked in by the marina, after a long drive through a beautiful neighborhood. It's at the bottom of the hill. Just gorgeous. From the outside deck to the inside quaint decoration, it is a comfy, cozy place for a drink with friends or a burger with family. Dress was casual to California casual, depending on your mood and time of day. Some criticism I have is one, the staff was closed lipped, at least with us they were. It was busy but there wasn't much conversation about the menu or drinks we ordered. I like some back and forth about what's popular, or "a great drink!" When you order. None of that, they were very quiet. Secondly, the valet group said not to park because we didn't have a reservation,

The location is great! Nice peaceful water views. We went on a Saturday evening w a last minute reservation. We were lucky to get a table. We sat inside because the outside was already spoken for. The staff was great! The food was good. The artichoke appetizer was delicious 😋. My cocktail was made perfect! FYI valet parking.

Great dinner, excellently prepared seared tuna dish that I can’t wait to order again! The menu is small and more limited but everything was delicious and very well prepared! Service was attentive without overbearing and the view is beautiful. Casual place with an upscale, approachable menu. Great date night spot

We tried this lovely restaurant this past weekend. The oysters were excellent! All the food was delicious, everyone loved the fish and chips and the burgers. The manager Tess was so kind and attentive! The renovation was done very tastefully. Defintely a must is Mattituck!

My experience tonight unfortunately confirmed my fears that this place is built to capture tourist revenue and is not meant to be a local watering hole, contrary to the article in the Northforker... My husband and I went after work on a Monday to avoid the larger tourist crowds. We chose to sit inside and the entire place had a great vibe, nice hostess, good music, and beautiful views. The cocktails we tried were great - the Spicy Paloma and the Pain Killer. They are expensive - like high-end cocktail bar in Brooklyn expensive, but worth the occasional splurge. The food was very meh, with really only 1 stellar dish of the many we tried. We wanted to do mostly apps and if the food was great, we were going to try an entree or 2. We were also scouting the place to see if we wanted to bring