Panatieri's Pizza & Pasta of Flemington

Great crust, sauce, and real mozzarella. Great family owned pizzeria. We are from North Jersey and were randomly in the area. So glad we stopped in here. The crust/dough, sauce, and quality of mozzarella were some of the best I've ever had in Jersey. And the family/staff are so sweet and friendly. We also ordered a dessert to go and noticed their to-go container is 100% natural & eco friendly, which is another great reason to frequent this place if you live/work nearby. Definitely recommend this spot!

Everything here is good. Best Pizza in the area, excellent slice selection, pasta dishes look and smell amazing. Chicken parm sandwich on garlic knock roll is insane good. The owner and staff are really nice and funny. If you haven't visited Panatieri's you are missing out. Update 12/1/2025 Went for lunch with my girlfriend and decided to try the pasta. Had the Chicken Sorrentino and it was absolutely incredible. The staff is always friendly and the food is always good. If you want some amazing Italian food, this is your only stop. Pizza is always great but was surprised by the quality and flavor of their meals. 10/10

What a great find! Delicious pizza and a variety of slices and sandwiches. Highly recommend their New Jersey slice which was like a Fra Diavolo 🤌🏾 and mushroom 🍄 slice. Service was quick and the gentleman cooking the pies was very friendly! If you are eating there, simply order what you want and grab a seat - they will bring it to you. I will absolutely go back again when in the Flemington area.

If you love a juicy pizza with extra cheese, then you will love Panatieri’s Pizza. I visited this location for the first time and was very pleased with their slices. My pizza was thin and crispy with lots of cheese and a good sauce. This is one of the best pizza slices I have had in Hunterdon County. Highly recommend trying this location when in the area. I will certainly be back! Great job 👏🏼

Our go to place for pizza!! The Jersey pie is my hubs favorite. I think we are here at least a week picking up slices for dinner. The staff and owner are so pleasant and nice! My son told me he wants to own his own pizza place one day, and I know it's because of panatieris! In about 10 years he might be working there! :)