Michelangelo Pizzeria

Mattituck, NY · Pizza restaurant

Rating
4.2/5
★★★★☆ 4.2
Reviews
20
Rank in Mattituck
#22
of 27 restaurants
City Percentile
8%
rating percentile
Address
Michelangelo Pizzeria, 10095 Main Rd, Mattituck, NY 11952
Phone
(631) 298-4100
Website
www.michelangelosmattituck.com
Status
Closed · Opens 11 AM

Michelangelo Pizzeria is a restaurant located in Mattituck, NY. It is one of 27 restaurants listed in Mattituck. Its 4.2-star rating is slightly below the Mattituck city average of 4.5 stars. There are 10 photos associated with this location.

Hours

Saturday11 AM–10 PM

Customer Reviews

★★☆☆☆ 2.0 Dulce Maria (wqd4bt) · Feb 2026

Honestly, the food was expensive and it was not that good, the pizza had a thin crust and did not had that much sauce and cheese. The buffalo wings were old, they tested like the frozen wings you get at your local market, they did not had sauce at all, and with the little they had, it did not taste like buffalo sauce. The vegetables were old and the ranch tasted like old cheese

★☆☆☆☆ 1.0 E M (Em) · Jan 2026

I don’t recommend this place. So overpriced. A shrimp Caesar salad was over $30 with four sad pieces of shrimp. They charge $4 per shrimp. Who does that? What a joke. What really turned me off, though, was the atmosphere. In my experience, the owner spoke to employees in a way that felt belittling and unprofessional, and made political comments that made the environment uncomfortable. Some remarks came across as offensive and inappropriate to be saying in a workplace, especially in front of customers. You can sense that staff aren’t treated with much respect. The tension is noticeable. If the owner knows you personally, you may get extra attention. If not, don’t expect much effort or courtesy. Personally, I wouldn’t work for this man, and I don’t feel good supporting a business with pri

★★★★★ 5.0 Sydney Flood · Apr 2025

Stumbled across this spot when going to the Dr next door. Pizza is fantastic here! Dough is soft and chewy, sauce is tasty and cheese is delicious. The garlic knots are 10/10. Speciality slices certainly stand out here. Thanks Carlo!

★☆☆☆☆ 1.0 Douglas · Nov 2025

Food is good, but the manager is highly unprofessional. I don't want him berating and cursing out his staff while I'm trying to eat, and I doubt anyone else does either Edit: apparently they'd rather lie to and gaslight customers than own up to poor behavior on behalf of ownership/management, if you needed any more reasons not to go here. Spend less time on reviews and more time on apologizing to your wonderful staff

★☆☆☆☆ 1.0 Elizabeth Harrington · Feb 2026

The worst ever. I would never go back. I ordered some thing from them on too good to go paid for it. Got a receipt and they refused to give me the food. Would never go back ever And they gave me all of this hassle over seven dollar order. Really? Never again there’s something wrong with this place as you can see by all the negative reviews.

Accessibility & Amenities

✓ Wheelchair Accessible Entrance ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Restroom ✓ Wheelchair Accessible Seating

Services

Pizza restaurantItalian restaurant

Top Restaurants in Mattituck

NameRatingReviews
Cedar House on Sound B&B★★★★★ 5.020 reviews
Iron Skillet★★★★★ 4.820 reviews
The Taco 105★★★★★ 4.820 reviews
Magic Fountain★★★★★ 4.820 reviews
Pookaberry Cafe★★★★★ 4.820 reviews
Mattituck-Laurel Library★★★★★ 4.819 reviews
Fiocha Pizza★★★★★ 4.720 reviews
North Fork Doughnut Company★★★★★ 4.720 reviews
Primavera pizza★★★★★ 4.720 reviews
CJ's American Grill★★★★★ 4.620 reviews

This listing is informational. Contact the business directly to verify credentials, services, and availability.