Isabella's Pizza & Subs

I've been wanting to try Isabella's since we moved to the area. I didn't have huge expectations but expected a lot better than what we received. We were greeted at all when we entered so we didn't know whether to sit or go to the counter. The food was horrendous. We started with the Cheese Arancini and they had absolutely no flavor. We ordered two 10" pizzas - The Matt and The Godfather. Both pizzas were significantly undercooked. The Matt had canned pineapple, which I didn't expect considering it's kind of peak pineapple season, and the chicken was GRAY and tasted bad. I literally picked all the toppings off except for the jalapenos in fear this was going to make me sick. My husband had The Godfather which he did not like. He said the sausage did not taste well and, overall, the pizza had

We came in with a group of 10, seeing the restaurant was empty probably should’ve been our first sign to leave. The food was pretty hit and miss, some were decent, some were terrible. The soft drinks tasted weird, the Carlisle pizza dough was undercooked, wings were overcooked. The prices were more expensive than we expected, around $27 for a large pizza, $14 for a small. The only good takeaway was the service, but good god it took so long for the food to come out.

I see a lot of negative things being said but I didn't experience any of that. Only thing I would say is my pizza was just a tad over cooked but I still enjoyed it. The seasoned fries were great. The waitress was great. I enjoyed the atmosphere, the music was enjoyable. My kids bacon cheese fries were good. Overall not bad at all.

Cool little place across from the train tracks. The restaurant looked like a rail car. The food was perfect. The pizza wasn't too crunchy nor too doughy. It was cooked just right. Cheesy Bread was great as well. The staff was awesome and very attentive.

And my experience, Isabella's pizza and subs, I had an amazing surfer. If I remember correctly, her name was Jasmine! She introduced herself- respectfully greeting all of us at our table. Honesty, for a pizza/sub restaurant, her surface was impeccable.... She was very responsive and expressive. I enjoyed how nice she was, and she had a really good smile on her. Jasmine was VERY sweet and even helped ensure we got our meals ASAP. The food was also very good.. I really liked it here at Isabella's and plan to visit you guys again soon. See you all soon, and hopefully Jasmine can be our server that day!!! Thank you again for your service(s) Kyle.