Finger Lakes Bed & Breakfast at Hutton Farm

A fabulous B&B with even more fabulous hosts! My husband & I stayed at Maggie and Mike’s B&B for our anniversary and it met all of our wishes. Maggie’s three-course breakfast each morning was 11/10, we will be missing that during the work week. Mike was a lovely “waiter” as he brought the meal out and started our morning with easy conversation and laughter. The home itself was so cozy. We loved sitting on the porch swing and enjoying our coffee while listening to the outdoors before heading off to the state parks & wineries nearby. The house was walkable to downtown for a variety of restaurants- which was very convenient when you’re trying all the wine & breweries around! Lastly- Maggie’s homemade soap was great! She included some in our room to enjoy with our stay and we ended up buying a

This is a beautiful, well maintained property, and Mike and Maggie are wonderful hosts. They are a fun, engaging couple who genuinely care about their guests. Maggie is an exceptional cook, so all the breakfasts were outstanding. We ordered some of her baked goodies to bring home, so we're still enjoying her culinary talents. While Maggie is busy in the kitchen, Mike provides the entertainment in the breakfast room with his great sense of humor while playing his waiter role with gusto. This is a B&B that really does feel like you are welcome guests in someone's home. Downtown Penn Yan is a short, pleasant walk from the B&B. This place definitely merits repeat visits!

​We recently enjoyed a wonderful weekend getaway with two other couples at your home. One of the couples stayed with you two years ago, raved about their experience, and we can now see why. ​We were completely blown away by the architecture and how immaculate and perfect every inch of the house was. It's clear that you, Maggie and Mike, have put so much thought and care into the place. The rooms are adorable and the breakfast, was absolutely delicious. We all agreed, we would love to come back again soon.

This is our 3rd stay (one was under previous ownership) and once again it was stellar. Maggie and Mike are amazing and when you stay, you notice all of the intricate details that make it so special. We stayed in the Library room which has a comfortable king sized bed on the first floor. Beautifully decorated and cozy with a cute reading nook it takes you back to a time before all of the rush! Maggie prepares a scrumptious 3 course breakfast with Mike serving and describing the dishes, throwing in some humor and recommendations for your day if you don’t have plans.

Had an excellent experience at the Finger Lakes Bed & Breakfast at Hutton Farm. Hosts Maggie and Mike met us when we arrived. Got a tour of the house and an overview of breakfast and all amenities. Room was lovely. Super clean everywhere. Breakfast was delicious. And the post breakfast conversations were wonderful - local happenings, food, experiences. Location was perfect - we were central for attending a wedding in Branchport and exploring the east side of Keuka (shops, antiques, wineries, waterfalls, etc...). We're highly confident that we'll be back to stay again. Well worth consideration if you're looking to stay in the Penn Yan area.