Fay's Country Kitchen

Perfect place to go alone for lunch. Was sat right away. Waitress was super nice. I had the side salad, a cup of soup and the turkey bacon club. The food is super flavorful while keeping it simple. Had to finish it all off with a slice of chocolate cake. Super rich and dense cake. The atmosphere was chill with retro decor. Feels like an old malt shop. The price is more than reasonable (around 25 dollars). Tried my luck at the claw machine on the way out and lost. Important to note that they are cash only and close at 2.

First time in Carlisle and decided to visit this place for breakfast, A bit small but plenty of seating available. Can get a bit crowded depending on where you sit. Also, can be a hassle finding a place to park. Lots of antique things to see around the establishment. Friendly staff and great service, had the breakfast special for $9.99 , comes with 2 eggs your way, bacon, toast, pancakes and a coffee or tea. Will be coming back if in the area again.

Food was amazing! Very fair priced. Service was great! Definitely would recommend to anyone in the Carlise area!

Old school diner on an older city block. Prices are very good. Food and service was very good. Unfortunately street parking and cash only. Yes, Lou was there.

We were in town for the 2025 spring car show. As vendors it is optimal to get to the fair ground as early as possible in order to beat the crowd. Thank God for Fay's. They start serving at 6am, but you can get there at 5:30ish and have a cup of Joe. The breakfast was very affordable and quite hearty. Over the course of the week I tried: The chipped beef, the sausage biscuits + gravy, the blueberry buckwheat pancakes, banana pancakes, hash, home fries and finally the eggs Benny. Everything was superb and set up the day for success. I would like to thank the staff for treating us so kindly from Tuesday morning to Saturday morning. It is important to keep in mind that Fay's is a cash only business.