City Hall Cafe and Grille

Let me just start by saying this place is absolutely superb! We came numerous times during our Pagosa Springs stay. We ordered take out twice for lunch and sat down twice for dinner. My husband and I don't eat much, so we always get plates to share. We firstly got a burger and my husband was charmed by the hostess who gave us our take out. She told him their dinner specials and immediately he wanted to bring me out for dinner to try it out. After a horrible experience at another restaurant, I figured why not. It is an adorable little tavern. It is small but charming. We were sat down immediately. The waitress recognized my husband immediately and came to greet me with the warmest smile! She told us the numerous specials they were having, and man was is a difficult choice. We ended up get

Rather disappointing after reading reviews. Service was lacking and long wait times for lukewarm food. Crab cakes weren't terrible but they were cold to lukewarm. My Caesar salad didnt have cheese and was so lightly dressed I barely tasted any flavor (look at the pic its just limp lettuce) and they hyped the seafood stuffed shells up so much I was looking forward to a redemption and after waiting close to 40 mins after we were done with our appetizer a lukewarm salty dish came out. I was only able to eat one shell it was too salty. Said all of this to a passing waiter as ours came so infrequently. She said thanks for the feedback and that was all. No manager ever came to apologize or make anything right. Im usually a 25% tipper regardless of food quality but the slow service with bad food

Some of the most delicious food we have had. The calamari was excellent! So tender and tasty. My eggplant stack was delicious and enough for a meal. We showed up right before closing.. they still sat us and served us amazing food( can't wait to eat the leftovers!). The staff is knowledgeable and our server was super nice. We highly recommend this place to eat a lovely upscale meal! Don't forget the drinks and appetizers!

The crab cakes were truly amazing—perfectly seasoned, tender inside, and beautifully crisp on the outside. You can taste the freshness in every bite. The chicken margarita was just as impressive: juicy, flavorful, and paired with a bright, zesty sauce that really brought the dish together. Both plates were memorable and definitely worth ordering again. Very impressed ❤️

I love this place. Let's start with the paradox of the eggplant tower. You're thinking to yourself, that's weird, maybe I should pick something I recognize. Don't! It's literally a mountain of happiness and joy that will exude unicorns and rainbows upon the first bite. Not lying, I told our wonderful server this verbatim to describe how much we loved the tower. The lamb chops were some of the best prepared I've ever had. Truly. I eat a lot of lamb; I'm half Lebanese. Wow, they were extraordinary with a unique taste you're not going to get anywhere else. The steak was also amazing. Here's the thing: it was really, really good, but the lamb chops were so extraordinary that this amazing steak took a back seat. Order both and share. You'll be glad. We loved the staff! They were so cool, fun, o