Carlisle Bakehouse

Yes.Just go! Although they have everything from delicious looking freshly baked apple pie to croissants, muffins, several flavors of cheesecake, and so much more, I went full Greek! Greek coffee ✔️ Galaktoboureko ✔️ Atmosphere ✔️ Friendly owners & staff ✔️✔️ Pricing ✔️ They have a small Greek grocery as well as a shelf of favorite traditional Greek cookies! Opa! Everything was perfect! They had the crowd to prove it. kalí órexi (good appetite) 10 out of 10 Highly recommend

This bakery is a total gem! Very welcoming, clean space! The cheesecake was delicious! I’ll definitely be back to try more of their pastries and coffee!

We got two cheesecakes for Thanksgiving and it was the best cheesecake we have ever had. Highly recommend. So fresh. Will be ordering more for Christmas! Thank you!!

If I could give this bakery more than 5 stars, I would! Every item tastes genuinely Greek and unbelievably fresh. The baklava is perfectly balanced—not too sweet—and the koulourakia and melomakarona bring back childhood memories. You can tell everything is baked with care and tradition. The service is friendly, the shop smells like heaven, and the quality is consistent every visit. This is the kind of place that makes you excited to go back. Highly recommend!

Delicious. Even my regular coffee with was extremely flavorful. It was my first time here and the gentleman was quick to assist me once he saw me eyeing the exotic tea selection for quite some time. I was pleased to see food and such from other countries. The tiramisu, the coffee, the tea, and the service did not disappoint. Great spot for us here in Carlisle!