Captiva Island Pizza

Very good NY style pizza. Get with extra cheese. Owner very nice guy. How anyone can give this place less than five stars doesn’t know anything about pizza. This is the very best pizza you’ll get in FL. Trust me.

Delicious NY style pizza, flavorful, crisp botton but soft and chewy inside. We loved our pepperoni pizza.

Really great pizza — bold, flavorful, and made with genuinely fresh ingredients. You can taste the quality in every bite. Fun, laid-back atmosphere too, making it a cool spot to grab a slice while on the island. Definitely worth stopping in if you are on Captiva.

I'm from Europe and didn't really like the pizza's here in the US. But these are amazing 👌🏼 Also a very nice and friendly guy 👍🏼 I will definitely go back here.

The website says delivery 5-9 pm Fridays and Saturdays - guy on the phone said, "We don't deliver". Toppings offered inaccurate.... but when you're on an island? You suck it up and try it! My 4 toppings were scarce, and basically all in the middle. Photos attached. So....Digiornos or this.... one you bring with, one you have to go pick up... so take your pick! They both put a lump in your gut and you're not hungry anymore!