Big Cheese Pizza - Clayton Crossings

If you want the best pizza in Clayton, Big Cheese Pizza is my go-to every single time. I’ve been coming here for a while and the quality never slips — fresh ingredients, great flavor, and pizza that actually tastes like people care about what they’re making. It’s the kind of place you proudly recommend to friends. That’s why the hours are so tough as a loyal customer. They close at 9 PM during the week and only stay open until 9:30 PM on Fridays and Saturdays. For a place this good — especially on the busiest nights — it’s honestly heartbreaking to see them close so early. I can’t count how many times I’ve wanted to order later and realized I missed the window. I love this place and want to support it as much as possible… I just wish I had more chances to. Extend the evening hours and you’

This place has the best pizza!! They taste better than little Caesar’s because little Cesar’s lost its flavor a while ago. The pizza and garlic bread sticks are always hot and fresh. The only thing I’m not a fan of is the cinnamon desert they have the icing taste is fakey. But we love their pizzas!

I purchased food here and when I got home I looked on the bottom of my receipt and saw that I could earn points for my purchase by signing up for their rewards. Of importance, I’ve been patronizing this business for over 5 years and I never knew they had a rewards program, as the staff never mention it. So I went on their website to try to sign up but that’s not an option so I called the store, their store # isn’t even listed on their receipt btw, and was informed that I can only sign up in store with my phone number. I asked her to do it over the phone and she said that she couldn’t because it can only be done at time of purchase. Note: I just purchased over $30 worth of food less than 30 minutes prior and not once was I asked if I wanted to sign up for the rewards or given any informatio

So every time I order through drive thru and they don't have my pizza ready due to their doing I have to pull to a front parking spot. However, I pulled up one time and the car in front of me was there for 15 minutes but they didn't make them pull up to the front parking spots and instead wasted my time. When I did finally get to take my order they once again weren't prepared with my food and told me to go to a front parking spot due to another car coming in. I guess as a Chicago Area person I don't get Southern privilege like you all do.

This pizza is sooooo good!! Hot , fresh and perfectly melted cheese. And they have this cookie that you pop in the oven for 2-3 minutes. It's so chocolatey and gooey. 😋