Watch Hill Proper

I was thoroughly impressed with this place, the service, and the food! The mocktails were fabulous! One of the bartenders made me a special Huckleberry mint mocktail bc I wanted something sweet…I loved it. The Sinfluencer sans the liquor was refreshing. I tasted two different presentations of Ahi tuna…I preferred the starter but both were great and a huge portion for the entree. We ordered the bolognese for the table and it was divine. The squid ink on the Caesar salad special added a nice touch of flavor and it had anchovies. I’ll definitely be back. I hate that I don’t remember anybody’s name because everyone was awesome!

WOW! Simply wow! I want to start by saying that Matt was the absolute best and if you can get him to be in charge of your table then you will have the best experience possible. The restaurant itself is beautiful and you are surrounded by hundreds of whiskey/bourbon bottles as well as barrels. It is very elegant but comfy at the same time. We had the following menu items: -Steak Tartare -Ahi Tartare -Lobster Roll -Diver Scallop -Ibérico Secreto -Duck Breast -Roasted Brussel Sprouts Everything was soooo good! I will definitely be back!

Tonight we celebrated my mother's 91st birthday with her friends at Watch Hill Proper. We had such a wonderful time. The food, cocktails and mocktails were all delicious. The employees, service, attention to detail and ambiance were all amazing. We were lucky to have David tend to our table, and the talented chef stopped by to chat with us for a minute. We will be back.

Fantastic evening. Started Saturday with the Blind Leading the Blind tasting before our dinner reservation. We were lucky enough to get Chris, one of the leaders and the tasting, as our server for the evening, which just added to our delight. Everything about it was top-notch and wonderful. The chef was out speaking with the guests and intermingling at different times. The food was fantastic. All in all it was a very top-notch evening and we will most definitely 100% be back.

I cannot adequately put into words how enjoyable our first time at Watch Hill Proper was. We had a fantastic server, Liz, and everyone in between was also amazing. The restaurant was properly staffed; never got below even half a glass of water, courses were timed impeccably, and the banter we shared between all the staff members elevated the experience even more. We had the duck breast, ahi tuna, cod, boar shank, and Brussels sprouts (not to mention the appetizers), and everyone's plates were either clean or boxed before we left. I already can't wait to return. 10/10 experience all around, well done to the entire staff.