Upper Crust Pizza Marathon

Such a great little pizza place!! The pizza is delicious, came out piping hot! Started with a small house salad that was also fresh & delicious! We had a group of 10 and knowing it’s small place we got there right at 5:00. We were seated right away and drinks came out fast and food not far behind. The place did fill up and real busy, but staff still kept checking on us and kept drinks filled. It did take a while to get our checks and then for them to come back and take our payment. But they were really busy!

Such an absolute gem in Marathon. The pizza was incredibly fresh and genuinely delicious. The hand-tossed crust was perfect and the pepperoni stood out with how well seasoned it was. I usually find most places skimp on seasoning, but this was spot on. We finished with the peach cobbler which was superb. What truly made the visit memorable was our server. She was so sincere and kind, and took care of us with such attention. She checked on drinks before we even thought to ask and seemed to anticipate everything we needed effortlessly. You could tell she genuinely enjoys what she does. The food alone would make me come back, but the service made the whole experience exceptional.

A hidden gem! We ordered the Large Beef & Pepper, and it was absolutely incredible — perfectly baked crust with just the right crunch, savory beef, and fresh, flavorful peppers. The balance of cheese and sauce was spot on, and you can taste the quality in every bite. Friendly service and a laid-back Keys vibe make it even better. Hands down the best pizza I’ve had in the area — can’t wait to come back!

I love the pizzas at this place; there's a variety for all tastes. The Cuban girl who works there is wonderful, very attentive and helpful. She makes you feel like family. I'll definitely be back.

Pizza tasted like my late italian grandmother's homemade pizza. Servive was excellent and the food tasted like memories and home. Thank you guys for the excellent dinner on our last night in Marathon! We appreciated it so much!