Sweet Savannah's of the Florida Keys

Someone said the best key lime pie in the keys so we gave it a try- and it was pretty darn good. Best… maybe. I’m guessing it’s as real as it gets- my palette may not be that refined! It was unquestionably good though! Kid got some electric blue ice cream with a purple cone… which yeah parents… but she loved it. Cute shop with lots of random candy and trinkets and baked goods. We got a cookie butter cupcake too- it was a bit dry but we came kind of late and it was the last one. Still tasted good though. Overall, you’ll enjoy it if you like sweets! Can’t go wrong.

Heard about this place and stopped in for some sweets. Loved the cupcakes and how each had its own filling and toppings. Had the key lime cupcake, coconut and sweet and salty cupcake. Got a few cookies as well, smores, macadamia nut and sugar cookie. Good prices for the authenticity of the sweets. Definitely recommend!

A very happy accident in finding Savannahs!! We tried a little bit of everything and of course all Key Lime. The ice cream was incredible, the cupcake was so soft and moist. Even the cookie was soft and delicious. Service was incredible and the entire shop was an experience!! A couple of very happy tourists!!

Just awful. We just came here and tried two absolutely beautiful cookies for $5 a piece. Unfortunately they tasted like candles or a glade plug in. 🤮 I understand wanting your cute little shop to smell like a boutique but the owner truly needs to decide if he/she wants to sell fragrance or baked goods; NOT BOTH. Why? Because if you sell candles or burn them within 10 feet of your cookies, your cookies are going to taste like soap and perfume. I will never shop here again, I’m disgusted and quite frankly, pissed.

This was our first time visiting Sweet Savannah’s, and wow—what an amazing treat! Hands down, the best ice cream in Marathon. The variety of flavors is impressive, and every one we tried was absolutely delicious 😋. We’ll definitely be back, and we highly recommend Sweet Savannah’s to anyone looking for a sweet and satisfying experience!