Udder Choice

This place is almost always busy when I go past. We stopped in to eat lunch there and were not disappointed. The sandwiches are full of meat - no skimping there! And so good. No skimping on the ice cream scoops either. The one take back was that we were surprised about the fact that no dress code/uniforms are required. The one waitress had shorts that her shirt almost covered them -they were that short. Didn't look very professional.

Utter Choice is a great place to get a delicious homemade soup, sandwich, wrap, or salad. The menue is simple, with just enough variety that even kids will be pick something out that they will like. My boys love it and I am a fan of the grilled ham and cheese sandwich with a cup of soup. They have some many choices for soup daily picking one is my only struggle. I love them all. The ice cream is reall good too. If you enjoy a Cracker Barrel type of restaurant, you will enjoy all the old signs and the ice cream scoop display.

Excellent prices. Reuben sandwich, chips, and ice cream were great. The chowder and ham and cheese melt were good. Excellent service and neat atmosphere. The wall with historic ice cream scoops is awesome!

Cute spot. The food was simple & done well, and very reasonably priced. Our favorite item was the cherry pie with a scoop of ice cream

I'm from North Carolina but each time I visit my Mennonite family in Pennsylvania I have to go to the Udder Choice. The food is always delicious the service is always great and I love the atmosphere. When available I get the split pea and ham soup with a salad or a grilled cheese sandwich but on this visit I had a Reuben with chips and and it was delicious. You can't leave without having dessert of either homemade cake pie or ice-cream and I had a cone of cotton candy ice cream and it was out of this world yummy.