Two Guys From Italy

I would like to thank the Staff for making a great night even GREATER👍we had a get together of family lost and now found. Without realizing,We stood past closing and they did not come to tell us to leave. When we realized we got up and thanked them very much for their patience. All I can say is THANK U TO ALL THAT HAD TIME TO MAKE OUR NIGHT A SUCCESS♥️❤️👍

We JUST picked up food from here. The calamari was cold, smelled off, and doesnt look particularly appetizing. Barely any sauce on the pasta, or runny at the bottom. It just tastes like the pasta. Would not order from here again, how disappointing for $45.

Ordered an Angel hair carbonara with sausage. What i received was a side of sausage in red sauce, and a dish or my carbonara swimming in atleast a cup of grease. The sauce had broken, honestly from the texture of the pasta it wouldn't surprise me if the microwaved my food and put it in the to go box. Also the side of sausage was interesting. I dont know anyone that would recieve my order and not understand I wanted sausage IN the carbonara, like im going to mix sausage and red sauce in a carbonara. But the pasta was so bad, I was glad to have the side of sausage so I could try to enjoy some food other than the salad my dinner came with. This was a to go order, if I ate in the resturant I absolutely would have sent my food back. Would not reccomend, would have been better off with one of th

Two Guys from Italy is better than my favorite pizza place in NYC - Sacco on 9th Avenue. And I've lived in NYC for 10 years. I was surprised how good everything was.

Got take out from here. The waiting time was a bit higher than initially told (about 40 minutes instead of the stated 20-25) but it’s still tolerable. It’s a busy place, after all, and for good reason. Even just waiting for our take out, the comfortable and cozy atmosphere paired with lots of friendly, smiling faces gave me a happy feeling. The food itself - classic American-Italian cuisine - ranges from pasta to pizza, and is not missing anything you’d expect. We also got wings, both of the bone-in and boneless variety, to go with our pizzas. Prices are a bit high but honestly, a personal pizza each is more than enough to satisfy. I wasn’t sure whether I want to rate Two Guys four stars because of high prices and very greasy wings and pizza or if the flavours win me over - but they did