Tony's Pizza Shop

Best pizza around! I would rather drive a few minutes further to get pizza that ALWAYS tastes great. Always worth the trip! Quality ingredients consistently 👌

Tried their pizza for the first time yesterday and will definitely return again for another. It’s a family owned business that’s been around for a long time, the type I like to support. Fresh dough, a traditional pizza oven, and just the right amount of everything, prepared by hand. Also enjoyed my conversation with the polite gentleman that took my order and made the pizza. The best part is I fed my family without dirtying a plate at home for five dollars per person, with leftovers. Can’t beat that!

We came in close to closing time and they were so patient with us, even when we had problems with the atmosphere! Plus I love square cut pizza! 😁 thank you

We drove to New York from PA n we stopped n tried their pizza. We absolutely loved it. 🥰

If I could give this place 0 stars, I would. They wouldn't dress the fingers for my salad and said it would be 45 minutes for 2 salads. It's Thursday and they are SALADS. They are served in thin cardboard to go boxes that soak up the moisture from the lettuce etc... my box broke and my salad fell on the floor. Disappointed is an understatement. And CASH ONLY? It's 2024. Every single restaurant I know of takes card. Evading taxes or...? Either way, shame on Tony's Pizza. Won't be returning. Sad because I used to get their pizza as a kid a lot and even that has gone down hill.