Strathmore Bagel Of Mount Sinai

My go-to bagel shop whenever I'm back on the Island. Great variety, nice and fresh, and plenty of egg everything bagels. Good prices too.

This place is the BEST. The guys working there CARE and put in the effort! I’ve never had an issue with my orders.

Had my mother’s funeral yesterday and did a catering order with them. Not only did they have the most disgusting presentation and not on platters as ordered, they did not cut the wraps in 1/3s as asked so instead of having 30 wraps we had 20, did not include the veggies wraps, did not platter the side salads, charged me $10.00 for 1 sliced tomato, lettuce, mustard and Mayo, no serving utensils and the list goes on. Beyond horrified that we ran out of food. Jump forward to this morning I called the owner this morning and he had zero interest in listening to what I had to say and discuss how to rectify the situation and all he said was if you weren’t happy dispute the charge and hung up on me. This is NOT what should happen when you get home from the cemetery after I had to bury my mom.

Even though the catalogue said 1/2 lb of cream cheese free (it even said inside the store), the rude employee said no, not any more without explaining why. I left very disappointed not for not getting the cheese but at the rude attitude of him. Terrible place. Fortunately for me it was a great day outside weatherwise.

I’m not sure how they managed to undercook an egg while also burning the bagel. My friend and I both got egg sandwiches with turkey, ketchup, spinach on an egg everything bagel. She had her eggs over easy while I had mine sunny side up. My egg was raw… looked like snot rockets were all in my sandwich. They were so cheap on the turkey and ketchup. Both bagels were burnt. I remember this place being good but I won’t be going back. I feel sick