Steak Loft Restaurant

Short version: This place is still awesome. Ignore the 3.9 stars and go there...even though they removed the salad bar. Longer version: I've been coming to Steak Loft for so many years, I don't even remember how I first learned of it. We recently planned on over-nighting in Mystic for my birthday (in the sub-freezing January 2026 temps), so just for giggles I checked the recent Google Reviews and was surprised to see only a 3.9 out of 5. Regardless, we decided to go there anyway for nostalgic reasons and were delighted with how great everything was; the ambiance, the drinks and the steaks were all fantastic. Our wait person, Lindsey was also super-nice and great to speak with. As for the mediocre reviews? After reading through them again, the "themes" I'm noting seem to focus on the dimly

Been dying to try this place and I can say I will give them another try. We walked in about an hour til close; it was nice and quiet. We got to sit where we wanted and the waitress ( all 3 ) was very attentive. The food from my opinion was a 7/10. The salad was amazing but the steak could have a bit of flavor. The chicken sandwich was good not dry at all. I really appreciate how attentive the ladies were; keep up the great work!!!

It was our first time at this restaurant, please please update your lighting!! Doesn't have to be bright, but it was even hard to read the menu during the day. We ordered fish and chips (amazing) and sirloin, salad, French onion soup, and mashed potatoes. My steak wasnt cooked too correct temp, and was a little bland, but was still decent. Possibly you should order it medium rare if you want it medium cuz it was overcooked. Everything else was good minus the fact that the server forgot my soup, i received it after my meal and the soup was comped. I will return to try the happy hour items.

Ive been all over the eastern half of the US from Chicago to Atlanta and up to Maine. This is my absolute favorite steak house. The ratio of quality to cost per pound is unparalleled. Every steak I've had here is cut perfect and cooked exactly how I asked.

Great food and wonderful staff. I love the bar here and the band was fantastic! It was Amy Winehouse’s birthday and I enjoyed the tribute song. My steak was amazing! Mashed potatoes are creamy and delicious. Great drink selection and great service.