Rosie's Pizza of Middletown

Fantastic pizza. Great owners. Called at 2:00 for a 5:30 pickup and was told it could be ready in 15 minutes if I wanted! This was awesome news as they took some flack when they first opened this location because of their ordering system (which is basically a simple call ahead process) Ordered a plain round and a sourdough square with pepperoni. Both pizzas were amazing, but the sourdough square was one of the best I’ve had. If you passed on getting pizza from Rosie’s because you’re afraid of ordering ahead, give them a try - you will not be disappointed!

We went in to try their sourdough pizza, it was really good. It had basil leaves and olive oil on top. They dont have a huge menu choice but we will be back when we want pizza.

Fantastic pizza, a really nice and clean restaurant, and the staff was really nice! Their dough is world class. Edit Sept. 30, 2025 - bought dough the day after we ate here and made a pizza at home. Their dough is a national treasure. Added picture of what we made at home with Rosie's dough.

Its not regular pizza. Its unique, its delicious its flavor, crispy yet soft! I had no idea what to expect when I went there but I was extremely pleased by the pizza! The staff is very friendly and kind! Ill be back next week for another slice !♡

I feel compelled to write a review due to the onslaught of negative reviews for this wonderful pizzeria. In my Italian and pizza obsessed opinion, this place has the best pizza around. The ingredients they use are high end, the dough they use is airy, light, and thin. Their square is light and fluffy while still maintaining a crispy bottom crust. Their round pies are AMAZING. I usually get the Cheese, Roni, or Meatball pizza. Before their Middletown location opened and When I was not at the shore, I happily drove 40 minutes to get their Pizza at their original PPB location. I am happy to now cut that time in half. I am a pizza snob and will refuse to get pizza from most of the local places due to how amazing Rosie’s pizza is. It’s not worth the calories to me to get pizza from anywhere