Nicholas Creamery

Got the Coffee and something with the rice crispy in a waffle cup. Flavor was perfect. Ice Cream was Perfect. The weather was perfect. Waffle cup was perfectly crisp, warm and sweet. Great value too - only $7.20 with tax. In Other parts of NJ this would be $10 and in NY maybe $12

Some of the best ice cream I have ever had. The flavors are unique, are high quality, and innovative. The collaborations with local businesses are wonderful too. Absolutely worth the 30+ minute drive

Nicholas’s Creamery is hands down one of the best ice cream spots around! The flavors are rich, creamy, and always fresh. You can really taste the quality in every scoop. They have a great variety—whether you’re into classics or want to try something new and unique, they’ve got you covered. The staff is always friendly and welcoming, which makes the experience even better. The shop itself has a cozy, local feel that makes you want to come back again and again. Definitely a must-visit if you’re in the area! And p.s try the Jersey corn 🌽 ice cream!

If you're feeling hungry, Nicholas Creamery is the ultimate destination for indulging in expertly crafted ricotta, delectable pies, and irresistible strawberry shortcake. This is the place to treat yourself to rich coconut ice cream, decadent chocolate waffles, and luscious chocolate custard—each bite is sure to bring a smile to your face. Pair your sweet treats with a glass of bourbon or cider, or go all out with a refreshing piña colada. Coffee lovers will be right at home with their exceptional iced coffee, chocolate frappes, and creamy blends that offer both warmth and comfort. Nicholas Creamery is also committed to your convenience, providing takeaway options for enjoying their delightful creations wherever you go. The friendly and attentive staff welcomes you with genuine warmth, cr

This place can compete with cold stone ice cream. My favorite ice cream is cherry garcia, and they have one that is called this is not your cherry garcia. Omg so good . Everything is fresh, and I can just taste the cream. My hubby's favorite is anything with chocolate and peanut butter, I didn't get the name of his. But he also said his was delicious as well. The only downfall is that they don't have any table's. Just some chairs out in the front facing the parking lot. I also want to say that the employees are all so friendly. The new one this year, Italian Rainbow cookie ice cream. Yummy! This Ice cream is so good that even in Freezing temperatures outside there is still a line 🙃