Trattoria Toscana

This restaurant is the kind of place that reminds you why dining out can be such a pleasure. Everything felt effortless—from the smooth seating process to the relaxed, welcoming vibe throughout the space. The menu is thoughtfully put together, offering a great balance of classic favorites and creative options. Every bite was packed with flavor and clearly made with care. The ingredients tasted fresh, the seasoning was on point, and the presentation showed real attention to detail. What really stood out was the staff. Everyone was professional, polite, and genuinely interested in making sure we had a great experience. There was no rush, no pressure—just excellent hospitality done right. The overall atmosphere made it easy to enjoy the meal and conversation, whether you’re out with family

We returned to Trattoria Toscana of Middletown to celebrate my birthday. Our evening was made special with an excellent recommendation and impeccable filleting of a salt baked whole bronzini. The table side presentation was amazing, the fish tasted incredibly fresh, moist and perfectly seasoned. A very impressive and unique dish to recommend. Our server Noa was fantastic—knowledgeable about the evening specials and very attentive, ensuring our glasses were never empty. We really enjoyed our experience there. Thank you.

One of the best Italian dining experiences in Monmouth County we have had!!! This is a high end experience and hands down the best. The environment is clean, warm, and inviting!!! Greeted promptly by several friendly host and staff upon arrival. The ambiance is cozy, and there was live entertainment. The entertainment was 1940s music. His voice was spectacular!!! Didn't want to leave so we could continue listening. The server was top notch. Noah explained how all food is made to order. There were no issues with our severe food allergies and dietary restrictions. Noah was bubbly and knows the restaurant's menu and food being served. She was kind, professional, funny, and thorough. She made us feel like we were VIP family. Now for the yummy part!!!! The food is delicious. Their menu provides

Hidden gem in Middletown. Food A+ Service was amazing. Atmosphere was perfect. Homemade pasta And homemade desserts phenomenal Would come back again. Realtor Peggy

One star because cocktails were good (all through the olives were mushy). Came at 7:15pm on Saturday night for a 7:30pm reservation. Was seated promptly, but the place was busy. We got waters and ordered cocktails. Ordered one appetizer to share (2 people) and it came in a reasonable amount of time, along with 1 additional cocktail. This is where it drops. We each ordered a pasta dish, carbonara and their special, grilled shrimp with rigatoni pesto burrata and tomatoes. All relatively quick dishes. By the time we ordered our meals the restaurant was half empty. One hour goes by and still no meal. We flag the waiter and he says from another table that food will be out in a minute. Another twenty goes by and still no food… a busser comes by and asks if we are all set with the Parmesan chee