Salvatore’s Pizzeria

I guess naturally you start with the food. Sooo good. LOVE the vodka slice! Pizza is absolutely delicious. But the atmosphere raises this spot up another level. Sal is so friendly and welcoming that you go in to see him as well as to get great pizza. Stop in if you haven't, it will be your new favorite spot.

The food in Sal's is absolutely delicious! I think the secrets in the sauce...or something lol bcz I've never tasted sauce like his!!! All the food is delicious there and I won't eat Italian food anywhere else! Sal your food is the 💣(bomb) 😂

I grew up eating Villa and was devastated when they closed. I just visited home and had to try Salvatore’s and was not disappointed. I ordered to-go and it was the same great slice and service I remember - the only difference is the name! The owner remembered me too which you can always appreciate from a small business. I don’t see them on social media so hope people can spread the news because I will be coming back every time I’m in town!

Wow. I usually wouldn't post about this stuff, but I just had a 1/2 meatball parm & a 1/2 chicken Cali... and WOW. Both were slammin'! Absolutely delicious! Large portion, not too much lettuce, right amount of Mayo & sauce... just perfect. Tough to find a decent sub around here.

We're always ordering pizza at my office, and we're usually disappointed. Not any more! Salvatore's Pizza is officially the office favorite. There wasn't one bad comment from anyone. That, in and of itself, is somewhat of a miracle. (We're a tough crowd.) At last, we have found the perfect pizza with the perfect sauce and, oh my goodness, the cheese and toppings! Thank you, Sal. We're so very happy you returned to Middletown!