Pompton Lakes Bakery

I picked up pastries for a party last minute and the owner threw together a nice platter for 50 guest so quickly! He was super busy but went out of his way to accommodate! This bakery is the best! And the pastries were a hit! The Neapolitan was especially good!

It's a little bakery with a big selection, I really appreciate places like this cause I feel not alot like around anymore . I bought some cookies, cake, n bread and I honestly feel like I under paid for everything.

Wow everything was so delicious! Melt away was fantastic. French croller donuts so soft and really tasty. Apple turnover delicious…. Pecan danish delish! We will be going back. Thank you!

Remarkable find. Some time ago, driving up from the city, I was asked to pick up a birthday cake at this bakery. While waiting I spotted the classic Kaiser rolls - which I know quite a bit about. I bought a half dozen and they were as wonderful as they looked. Most rolls labeled as "Kaiser rolls" in other stores are not authentic. Genuine Kaiser rolls have unique characteristics including an outer crust and a soft denser inside. They are rare to find (in New York City, generally only in the outer boroughs). These were the real deal – and baked right on premises - in a family owned bakery. I always stop by now when I'm in the area. I stock up on Kaiser rolls and generally pick up one or two other items. Everything freshly baked right there. A delightful family owned business. The lady w

I am not really fond of this place but I was so excited to try for the first time. The cake taste stale and the frosting definitely had a weird taste. I am also very shocked that I spelled the name out for this woman and she still spelled “Gordon” instead of “Jordan” so I did try to fix it. She also did not care at all to spell birthday out so she didn’t even bother to put the “y”at the end. 👎 definitely will stick to Gencarelli’s in Wayne but I guess thanks for the cake anyway.