Randy's Homemade Ice Cream

Always on the lookout for delicious homemade ice cream and Randy's did not disappoint. Hands on owner Randy whipping up some unique and traditional flavors. I sampled cinnamon rice pudding which was amazing. I went with Pumpkin Patch and Vermont Maple both excellent choices. My wife enjoyed her strawberry. Place was busy for a Sunday night and everything ran smoothly. I highly recommend Randy's and look forward to trying more flavors.

Update: After arguing with Randy on Facebook, he finally agreed to refund me. Since my boyfriend had paid for the ice cream, he went back in to get the refund. Instead of honoring his word, Randy refused, screamed at him, and even slammed his hands on the table. His own son had to push him in the back to stop him from escalating further. Randy then claimed that since I made the complaint, I was the one who had to come in. So I did. What followed was a full-blown screaming match. Once again, his son had to physically push him to the back because he was completely out of control. I’m sure Randy felt real tough getting in a woman’s face and shouting “don’t come back.” This man is an absolute weirdo. Original post: Randy just lost my business for good. I’ve been to this shop several times a

As a local this place is the real deal! I always pass by, but never walk in. I see the long lines and I'm wondering why are there always long lines. Well now I know the ice cream is out of this world. Quick service! Great prices! And you get the bang for your buck. For eight bucks I got this huge cup of ice cream. It was absolutely amazing especially on a hot day. The two guys working, they were super friendly and super helpful, and I asked them if they had caramel and they offered all their caramel selections. Definitely try the Milky Way caramel out of this world delicious. So happy to enjoy homemade ice cream made by a local business in town absolutely great work guys!

This is our next to last stop on the NJ Ice Cream tour (only one more to go!). Turns out that Randy was the person who organized the whole thing. Thanks Randy!! The tour has been great fun. The Triple Threat Browning was one of the best ice cream we’ve had. Creamy and crunchy at the same time, with a deep, delicious flavor. Scoops are generous. Lots of families. Great cow art on the wall. Accessible♿️ Street parking.

Randy’s Homemade Ice Cream is an amazing experience! Carefully crafted and unique flavors that are out of this world! You can’t leave with just one! So good! His Cookie Monster, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup and Cannoli flavors are just some of my favorites. A must visit! 🍦😄