Pizza Pie Cafe

This pizza pie Café location is so much better than the Rexburg location. My wife and I came late at night to enjoy some pizza buffet but this time the pizza was tasting absolutely delicious. More than it ever has in Rexburg. The pizza tasted pretty fresh, considering it was a buffet. A few things that tasted like they had been sitting out for a while for example, there were these Oreo knot looking things and they looked delicious but then when we tasted them, they tasted stale and like they had been sitting out for a long time. The pizzas that I would say are definite must: The combo pizza, Hawaiian pizza, the firefighter And my wife enjoyed the potato pizza. We were sad not to see the barbecue chicken pizza there this time as it’s one of my favorites. One of the pizzas that we did not

I am normally a fan of this place, but last night royally changed that. Towards the end of January I had called and made a reservation for my daughter to have her birthday party there. I was told it would be treated as a call ahead, but it wouldn’t be a problem. Well, fast forward to last night I received a call about 15 minutes before our scheduled time that they may not be able to hold those tables for us. I told them I would be there in just a few minutes. Less than 5 minutes I was there with about half of our party and Th way had already given our tables away. We never got the room we were supposed to be in and where we were put was spread out a bit. I highly recommend if you’d want to have a larger party… don’t go to pizza pie cafe. A call ahead/reservation means nothing to them.

The food was sort of the definition of OK. I've been to another Pizza Pie Cafe in Rexburg that feels like their pizza was better quality. Every time I went up to the buffet for more pizza, 2/3 of the trays were empty, which just left me wishing I could have the pizza listed on the label. There was food all over the floor and overly loud. I am usually a very positive restaurant reviewer. It wasn't the worst, but like I said, it was all just OK.

I suggest coming at opening time, the pizza is the most fresh! I really enjoy the pizza when it is most fresh, but because it's an all you can eat buffet sometimes the pizza stays under the lamp and just gets real dry... I really enjoy their salad bar and the pasta bar! They have good options to choose from, and not only do the have regular pizza but they have dessert ones too! I'd recommend it to anyone to at least try it!

We took our kids here because our oldest is a pizza hound so we thought we would check it out. First off this place is busy so don't just plan on a quick in and out meal. They have everything from a fresh salad bar, build your own pasta bar and large assortment of all you can eat pizza slices. Overall I felt the price and quality were a fair value and with the different assortment of foods there's something for everyone. Our family will definitely be back in the near future. Edit: some time has gone by and I feel the luster of this place has worn off. The last couple of times we've been there the pizzas have either been empty or cold. During my last visit the pizza bar was never any more than 40% full. Another thing I've noticed the last 2 times is all the pizzas taste like they have suga