Pantera's Pizza

*Edit 2/10/26* Updated Rating Had a pleasant experience working with the owner. I want to reiterate, as I stated below in my original review, the pizza was great and the restaurant prepared my pizza really quickly. The only issue was with the delivery (which was NOT Pantera's fault). Not being able to have any recourse with DoorDash as the end consumer was the problem. In the specific circumstance of this one delivery, it was likely akin to a combination of poor judgment + super bowl sunday where the driver thought other delivery orders would be prepared faster than they did, but, again, it was the driver's own judgment to sit and wait for ~40 min for additional orders while our food was getting cold. ------ We ended up having a delivery. The restaurant was great; the pizza, even on Supe

This is without a doubt or favorite pizza restaurant in the area. We drive 30+ minutes twice a week for two reasons... the pizza and the awesome salad bar. Very friendly and professional staff who not only serves excellent food but maintains one of the cleanest restaurants we've seen anywhere. And that's saying a lot. Definitely worth making the trip!

This is my first time eating at Panteras pizza. The pizza was really delicious and I will definitely come back multiple times just to eat here! Drove from Watseka Illinois to come and eat here for my mom’s birthday! This is her favorite pizza ever since it was located in Watseka until they closed! It made my moms day and her younger years, she said pizza still taste the same like it did in the 80s!

Gluten free pizza was awesome. Regular pizza crust was bland.

What happened to the recipe? It’s a very noticeable change. Back then when I was younger, my family and I would always get Panteras. The dough was slightly sweeter and looked like it was given time to rise. The sauce and cheese was slightly tangy, and it was memorable, like the pizza had personality. Now, the pizza flavor profile made a complete 180, and tastes exactly like Pizza Hut. The crust is the same as Pizza Hut as well, sauce is stale. It changed completely. Such a disappointment because this pizza place seemed so down to earth and family oriented. Now it just blended into every other pizza place. Such a bummer.