Original Italian Pizza

Stopped by for lunch on a road trip and had the best pizza my family's ever tried, hands down! We got the large 16" Chicken & Broccoli pizza with a garlic base (amazing), and it was hot and crispy. My dad usually doesn't like cheese, but he loved this one because it wasn't too oily. Even the crust was delicious. For $25, this was more than enough for a family of 3, around $8.33 per person. Their wings were great too - perfect amount of seasoning. We got a salad for health, and the owner gave us their bread on the house, which was warm and fluffy on the inside. It was very fresh, and paired with butter was gold ⭐️. The owner and staff were so generous and kind. Loved eating here, they have cooking & baking down to a science!!! Highly recommend.

This is about 300 miles away from my hometown. We only get to go there when we go to Niagara Falls. We have made stop about 6 times so far and loved the great food every single time. The owner values the real deal. Customer service, best and fully satisfactory meals. He and his team are awesome every single time we visit. Always felt satisfied with food and service.

My family & I always thoroughly enjoy eating OIP no matter if it's pick up or the occasional done in, the food is delicious and always consistent (which is hard to get these days), the staff are always so friendly and kind, even help me carry food to my car when I pick up an order. Very highly recommend this place if you're dining out as a family, very kid friendly place. We will always choose oip.

I dont know why, but personally, i receive unwelcoming stares and bad vibes when entering this establishment. I went a few other times just to make sure, and I do not feel good spending my money here AT ALL....this location is also very lazy sluggish and CLEARLY only working for a check. The pizza is never fresh when i order it, ive ONLY had reheated pizza here. I get sometimes, but everytime? I would love a "fresh" slice sometimes. Customer Service is a least priority at OIP CORNING.

Mixed review, 1st timer last week, and cheesesteak was great so went back today to try few more dishes, eggplant parm was good as was pizza and garlic knots but the wings were worst ive had in long time, way overcooked and dry, barely edible but when I went to pick up it was pretty busy in there so ill assume it was just an off day in busy kitchen and im going to try again and edit my review as deserved with a better experience