Aniello's Pizzeria

Awesome New York pizza restaurant. So authentic. We ordered the Garlic knots, Sausage roll, Meatball Parmigiana and Sausage Parmigiana. Everything was perfectly cooked and Delicious. Everything we both hoped for. Great atmosphere too.

My husband took me here for the first time recently. We ordered a large chicken wing pizza and a tossed salad. It really didn't take long to get our food. The pizza had an amazing taste (and a nice side of bleu cheese). The crust was perfectly thin but not hard. The salad had lots of toppings and it was a heaping portion. For me personally it had too much dressing. The decor was cool with old pictures and lighting. The staff were all very friendly and helpful even when they were getting their lunch rush. I would go back again if in the area for sure.

Absolutely phenomenal pizza! It was crispy, foldable slices with that perfect New York chew and char. The sauce is on point and the cheese is generous. It's the crust though what hits that classic thin but sturdy balance. It’s the closest thing to a NYC slice you’ll find outside the five boroughs. Plus, the staff is warm, fast and genuinely welcoming service that matches the quality of the pie.

If you are looking for the absolute best Pizza, with the crispiest, most flavorful crust and delightful and fresh toppings, as well as magnificent garlic knots and a glorious salad and, finally, with the greatest fountain drink mix you'll find in this part of the state - you have found it in Aniello's Pizzeria. After a beautiful hike up Watkins Glen and back, we were extremely hungry, and this food absolutely hit the spot. The salad was big enough for 3 people to share, and the garlic knots were honestly an amazing surprise with how crispy and light and flavorful they were. We had the chicken wing on one side of a large and the Mediterranean on the other side of that large. It was glorious. Magnificent. And an aggressively reasonable price. To top it all off, the service was awesome a

My wife and I had building supplies to obtain at Home Depot my gal is like let's try this place on market street I have never been here so our day has begun. We parked on the corner and wandered in, the atmosphere was very NYC type, everyone kind of rolled with the atmosphere, everyone seemed to enjoyed the food and people they are sharing with to me looked amazing. Our pizza arrived in about 15 minutes, it was delivered to our table, the gentleman brought us silverware, excellent. Everything looked clean and on point. The tables had a roll of paper towels and chemical cleanser, excellent we wiped the table down while chatting and enjoying the day. The pizza extra cheese / mushrooms and sausage was hot and amazing. My wife a real pizza GODDESS thought it amazing, she loves the whole scenar