New York Pizzeria

This place has incredible wings and decent pizza. The wings are really a standout but the pizza is just average. I would come back here for the wings and to try the other food. The service here really stands out, excellent service all around.

Best pizza in Cooperstown. Always stop by here every other Friday night for a take out order. The prices are reasonable, easy spend around $50 for four people. even on the busiest of Friday nights when I call my order it is usually ready in about 20 minutes. The staff is always friendly, especially Kayla. She recognizes me on site, is always friendly, and even when I call in my order and give her my name she knows exactly who is calling. If you stop by definitely give the habanero mango wings a try.

Cool spot to get a slice in Cooperstown. It was just outside of downtown which made parking WAY easier. Ordered at the front - got a Stromboli (roll) and a slice. Roll was piping hot and was loaded with ingredients - you pick 5. Slice was solid too. Overall it was a good quick meal for a decent price. I would go back when in town

It’s a pizza place. Order a whole pie or by the slice. Slice starts out as a basic cheese slice and add toppings of your choice. Nice crispy undercarriage. Toppings were flavorful and abundant. Chicken Ranch Salad is disappointing. Literally just fried chicken, lettuce, tomato and Nothing else. Waste of money for the most part.

The pizza crust was very good. The sauce was ok. If you like to add condiments like Parmesian, garlic powder, pepper flakes, oregano, etc... give them 5 stars. Fair priced. They do use bromated flour, but for me that's not an issue.