New York Pizza - Carbondale

Warm and inviting establishment. They have a lunch special Monday through Friday from 11am to 3pm. Any slice with a side salad and soda for only $13. That’s what we got. We upgraded to a Caesar salad and it was fantastic. Very flavorful and also not overpowering. Fresh ingredients. Pizza was good too and also fresh. The slices are HUGE. Overall, I would recommend this place!

I ordered “The Works” pizza and it had no flavor, pizza was cold and we clearly saw it got delivered to another table, they took two slices off and then they told the guy it wasn’t theirs. Then the guy took the pizza tray to the back and put two slices in the same tray. The salad was the only good part of this restaurant.

Good chicken! Great cheese steak sandwiches. Nice people and open till 9:30. Delivery with door dash.

First the Person who took my order was very rude! They messed up our hot wings. And put all slices on top of each other! And As you can see the slices were burnt! As a local we try to support local businesses but this was bad! Never going back!

Pizza is Great. Salads are Even Better. Hospitality is 5 Star. I enjoyed a casual dinner here outside on the patio with my family. The manager, Matthew went above and beyond to check in on us. Will be back soon. Thanks!