Mystic Mountain Pizza

Everything we ordered was perfectly cooked and delicious. We got the Chet Styx and a half Meat Lovers / half Mystic pizza — both were absolutely amazing. The restaurant itself is uniquely decorated with quirky alien themes and references to movies and shows, which we loved and made the whole visit even more enjoyable. Despite it being a busy lunchtime with only two waitresses, the staff was incredible. They were friendly, attentive, and handled the crowd like pros. Highly recommend stopping by Mystic Mountain Pizza!

Stopped in for lunch today. We thought getting there around 2 PM would beat the busiest time, but we were wrong. We waited just about an hour for the two pizzas we ordered, Thai dye and Pickle. We didn’t mind the wait too much as we passed our time playing Pac-Man and eventually figuring out the wi-fi password so we could browse the web. The pizza was great. We both thought the pickle was the better pizza. I thought the pizzas were personal pan, but we quickly realized they were full size pizzas. 1 pizza will easily feed 2 people. My only recommendation would be to give people bread or something when the wait is as long as it is. Also, advising people of the wait. We were not told that when we were sat, but as I was browsing their little shopping area I heard them telling others the wai

Very gimmicky decorations, that may appeal to some. The breadsticks seemed store bought with extra cheese thrown on top. Marinara was ok. Pizzas were not to my taste because the pizza sauce was on the tart side (toppings were good though), and we ordered a buffalo pizza without blue cheese crumbles and still ended up with it on the pizza. They were nice and apologetic. If you want something besides chain pizzas give this place a try, but overall I won't come again. Edited: I was being generous while making this review, and initially gave it 3 stars, having received the note from the owner despite being polite over the experience as "good!" for saying I wont be coming back, I will change it to a 2 star and also add that the waitress even told the owner who was in the back, chewing on food w

Absolutely fantastic! Our new favorite pizza joint. Great service and great food! We went at lunch during a festival downtown. Seated immediately and food and service were impeccable.

I loved everything about Mystic Mountain Pizza. The atmosphere is so endearing with all kinds of pizza themed and psychedelic decor. The service is attentive and friendly. We got the meat lovers pizza and they were able to accommodate switching up an ingredient for us. The pizza was amazing with generous toppings and a crust which was crispy on the outside, and tender on the inside. It was cooked to perfection without being burned as some wood fire pizzas are. The sausage on the pizza was the best I've ever had...almost as if it was homemade. It was an all around great meal.