Mt. Sinai Bagel & Deli

Visited: Weekday Wait time: No wait Price per person: $10–20 Noise level: Quiet, easy to talk Parking: Plenty of free parking (large lot) Overall Experience Mt. Sinai Bagel Cafe is a great new addition to the area and offers a very comfortable, clean, and welcoming experience. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted politely and felt genuinely welcomed. Food Quality The bagels were fresh, well made, and clearly baked with care. The standout for me was the everything bagel. What made it special is that the seasoning was on both sides of the bagel, not just the top. That alone made every bite consistently flavorful and memorable. The cream cheese was excellent and well balanced. I tried both the veggie cream cheese and the jalapeño cream cheese, and both were delicious. The jalapeño cr

We have been coming here since it opened and their food is delicious! They always greet you with a warm and welcoming smile. My husband LOVES the egg sandwiches. I enjoy their roast beef sandwich ( picture below). The prices are very reasonable as well. We truly enjoy eating here !

Mt. Sinai Bagel & Deli is truly a neighborhood gem. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted by some of the friendliest owners around they make everyone feel like a regular. Their warmth and genuine hospitality set the tone for a great experience every time. The shop itself is spotless. Everything from the counters to the seating area is clearly well cared for, which makes enjoying your meal even better. It’s obvious they take pride not only in their food but in maintaining a clean and welcoming environment. And the food absolutely delicious. The bagels are fresh, perfectly baked, and packed with flavor. Breakfast sandwiches are made to order with quality ingredients, and you can really taste the difference. On top of that, the prices are very reasonable, especially considering the po

First time going here. I ordered two egg sanwhiches and a few bagels. Egg sandwiches were excellent but bread could’ve been a little fresher. Bagels were probably best in the area now that better on a bagel shut down in miller place. Looks like we found our new bagel store! Staff was super friendly! Interior was spotless and updated. Looks great!

We stopped in today because we happen to be passing the store on the way home from food shopping. From the minute the person behind the counter walked away with our order, we knew it was going to come out wrong. Unfortunately, we were correct. We wanted two bagel sandwiches (BEC), both on egg everything bagels but one of the bagels we wanted toasted with butter. We received one egg everything bagel and one egg bagel. Neither one was toasted and the bacon was so undercooked we needed to microwave it before eating. While we were waiting, another customer walked back in and returned a sandwich she didn’t order. I understand every business has bad days but in an area where there are a bunch of really great bagel stores, I think you always need to strive for perfection. As a side note, many wor