Mastro's Ice Cream

Prices are best in show, blue ribbon winner here! For as high as they can be that is, one scoop is $5. A 20oz. Boston Cooler $8.02 which came to 9.50 after $1 tip and tax... I don't get how it's 47 cents to get 4 oz more for a medium yet it's $6 to get 12 oz more for a large. What math is that?! Won't be back again we'll stick to Country Dairy right down the road, waaaaaaayyyyy more affordable and a better menu with so many more options. Faster their also, the line we waited in we almost didn't but stuck around. The Boston Cooler we got just tasted like a vanilla malt with caramel maybe idk but they're is supposed to be Vernors and I didn't see that come in anywhere. Ooooooh yeah I almost forgot, there was a guy holding the door for people and looking at his phone that seemed like he'd be

Local mom and pop shop with hard ice cream and soo many different flavors and everyone is just as good as the last. They have homemade waffle Cones and bowls some are dipped in chocolate and sprinkles. My personal favorite flavor is the Banna pudding. Staff was very friendly we will definitely be back.

Love the nostalgia of this long time family owned business in The Shores. I appreciate the variety and sugar free and dairy free options available. Upon every visit I have had over the many years, the owner and staff has been very friendly and as sweet, if not sweeter than the ice cream! I’ve even witnessed them deal with a customer that has been rude and obnoxious. Kudos to the staff calmly handling the situation with kindness and patience. I sympathize with anyone in the service industry as some people can be judgmental and rude. 🍦🍨

Good ice cream, insane pricing. I feel like everything is expensive these days, but I’ve been coming here over the last few years. It’s been a while but I seemed to remember it was around $4-5 for a single scoop. Not cheap but not crazy. Well, I just paid $16.50 today for two ice creams. Nothing fancy. Two single scoop servings, one with hot fudge on top. I could have bought a whole half gallon at the store. It’s really good Guernsey ice cream, but I won’t be back until they lower the prices or the economy catches up with their crazy inflation. Sad. I always preferred the ice cream here versus Wally’s, but I guess I’ll just for a cheaper option. Won’t be back anytime soon. It’s a shame.

Mint chocolate shake and the turtle sundae. Order them and thank me later ☺️