Makahoa Pizza Company

Super great pizza and very friendly staff. New York style, and huge whole pies so be aware if you aren’t up for that much food when you’re ordering. Definitely a favorite!

This review comes in late. I was there in January and it's now July. What an amazing pizza! Actually, best pizza I've ever had. Be there early or call right when they open, because they can get busy. I'd still wait 2+ hours for this pizza though, it's that good. I can't wait to come back, because my wife and I still talk about it. If you're the first person to order, you'll have the shortest wait time. We only waited about 15 minutes. Which is just perfect because we hopped over next door and got some beers.

Best pizza on this side of the island. They use flour from Italy & it doesn’t bother my gluten intolerance. Better to order in advance because they do make to order & wait could be 15-30 mins

Awesome pizza, service, and experience! Large pizza was $16 and so much better than any pizza we've had on the island. Crust is delicious and has a great texture. The sauce was simple and tasty, reminding us much of the flavors while living in Italy. Jeff, the owner, was awesome and friendly and said he styles it much like what he grew up with in New Jersey. Looking forward to returning soon!

So here’s the thing: We love pizza. I’m from Chicago, my husband is from New York, so we know good pizza. This place knows how to serve up! Pizza is loaded with toppings- not just a little blob here and there with an occasional olive. It was covered! (We got the Garlic + Greens) Perfect ratio of sauce to cheese to toppings. Crust had a satisfying crunch to it. Our kids kept saying it was THE BEST PIZZA they’ve ever had. We basically licked the box clean. But that’s not all— the girl working there was super friendly and kind. We watched her interact with the other customers while we were eating and were impressed with how she interacted with everyone.