John's Of Arthur Avenue

I’ve lived in Port Chester for quite some time and have never tried John’s of Arther Avenue. After ordering the Buffalo chicken pizza, I’ll definitely be more of a regular. The service was fast and take note we came in for an order on a Friday night and it was packed with people which was great. I understood why after taking my first bite. First Buffalo chicken pizza that added celery and it stuck with me ever since. If you want a great Buffalo chicken pie, go to John’s!

I felt welcomed as soon as I walked in and the service was great. I ordered the plain and the grandma slice. Both were excellent!! So Crispy and fresh! This is now my go to spot in the area! WOW! 🤤🤤🤤 P.S. Pics next time, I was HUNGRY lol

Excellent. Best Pizza ever . The slices are huge and very good. Love the garlic knots too .

I recently moved to the area and usually find myself driving back to my hometown to get pizza, I decided to stop here as it’s 2min from my new home. I got the pepperoni pizza and it was really yummy with good flavors overall. I will come back to try again and I am hoping for consistency.

I visited this place last night while in town from South Carolina. I was trying to try as many Sicilian pies as possible while I was up that way. I split a piece of Sicilian and tried a slice of pepperoni. I thought the pepperoni slice was good but it could’ve been cooked a little longer to crisp it up some. It was also a little bit greasier than what I was used to. The Sicilian piece was pretty good with the extra sauce on top. This probably could have been a little bit crispier too but it was still tasty. It was good and now that I know I would come back and ask for everything to be left in just a little longer.