Johnny Pizzas & Pastaria

We thoroughly enjoyed our meals during our second visit in less than a month! The pizza is absolutely phenomenal, and the chicken wings are a personal favorite. However, I feel that customer service could use some improvement. On both occasions, I had to wait longer than expected at the front door for assistance. During my latest visit, I ordered a drink shortly after 9 PM, only to be informed that they stop serving alcohol at 9 PM. While I understand this might be a house policy, it’s not consistent with the closing time advertised. The machine message states that they’re open until 10 PM, and I assumed the same would apply to alcohol service. It would have been helpful if the server had mentioned that last call was approaching around 9 PM. Despite this hiccup, the food continues to impr

Great venue. Perfect for a light bar vibe dinner or family gathering. Our waitress Julia was wonderfully and very prompt with drinks, food and came by multiple times to check on us. Pizza and Lasagna were delicious.

I have gone into Rosati's/Johnny Pizza as long as they have both been open. I have never had a bad meal and I have eaten almost everything on the menu. I celebrated my birthday there last Friday with 18 people. They have always been very accommodating and easy to work with when having larger groups. Their core staff have been together for many years so that gives you an idea about the environment. When friends come to town, that's where I take them because of the food and service.

We have lived in Oconomowoc for just over 3 years and have ordered from Johnnys/Rosattis about once a month. It’s our go to for ordering pizzas because it’s always fresh, delicious and the hostesses that we pick up from are ALWAYS polite and helpful. I definitely leave a bigger tip because the experience has always been positive. I will also add that it’s a great price point and I consider them reasonably affordable. I was hosting a birthday dinner for my mother in law’s 97th birthday and she wanted spaghetti and meatballs. I ordered a few days prior for takeout. I had to order the meatballs separate from the pasta, but it was really worth it. We got 10 meatballs and I thought they were going to be small but I was shocked to see how big they were. Not too big but big enough. Again, everyt

Johnny pizzas & Pastaria is by far the BEST pizza on the PLANET! Perfect flavor, crispy, perfect amount of toppings. Gosh I wish I could do this at home but I know I'll NEVER be able to replicate such perfection! Please never change the recipe. 👌