Jim & Nena's Pizzeria

I got a gluten free cold sub & it was pretty good. The bread was a little crisp for me, but thats a personal preference. They piled on plenty of vegetables on top of the meat & cheese. My husband got an Italian sausage stromboli & it looked awesome! This is also not an option I've seen many places! Just a side note- Not a lot of indoor tables, there are more large benches & booths.

I ordered a GF sized sub online and got a 7". Despite not getting oil and vinegar, my sub roll was soggy. Will not eat near again.

This place used to be so good. The last 2 times we went there the food was horrible. No taste, burnt fries, tuna boat completely runny. Very disappointing.

To be honest, I was disappointed after all the times I've heard the name around York. The pizza was so-so. The crust was floppy and a tad undercooked and the cheese not very high quality compared to other pizza restaurants I've been to. Perhaps they were having an off day, so I would give them another chance.

The pizza here is New York style and is awesome! Crispy dough, fantastic cheese, and treat yourself to a cannoli for dessert- DELISH! Mario, the owner is cooking, waiting tables, and still taking time to talk to his customers. Great young man! Give it a try- you won't be disappointed!