Moonlight Cafe

We made a trip to Dover to give the cafe a try based on the reviews and frankly came away disappointed. The place had a cozy feel even if it was a little noisy from the kitchen. The servers were friendly and attentive. The food, however, was pretty bland, not much flavor or spice at all whether it was the calamari, veal piccata, or handmade meatball lasagna.

Great little place , food was absolutely delicious, service great and all it’s missing is a little it of music … we got crab dip, chicken Marsala and shrimp champagne- total bill $73 , portions was huge and we took half of it to go. This place is BYOB . Definitely worth the stop, Great Italian food

I had the bacon wrapped filet. It was not really tender and didn't have much flavor. The salad was very good and a nice size. The broccoli florets were really good! The French onion soup was a crock full of croutons with very little soup topped with cheese. Basically mushy bread topped with cheese. It's a small café that's crowded. The service was good.

Great food. Large portions served hot. Friendly staff. Just a little loud and a little cozy for seating. 😊

For years, we've been told how this is the best Italian food in York, so we decided to give it a try. The first thing to notice is that the seating area is very small with a lot of tables. The lighting and overall atmosphere is not what you expect from a high-end Italian restaurant. No romantic date nights here, but we got the small table in the corner by the kitchen, and that's the closest you will get. It's BYOB, so we brought a nice bottle of wine, and once they saw it, they brought us glasses and a corkscrew. The fact that it's BYO does save a lot compared to buying by the glass. We started with the spicy fried green beans, which were very good. The marinara sauce was a very simple standard american-italian marinara sauce. Which I believe would be good over a classic chicken parm or