Heavenly Sweet Bakery

We are so beyond happy that we chose Heavenly Sweet Bakery for our wedding cake & cupcakes! We received so many compliments on how delicious everything was and they were both decorated beautifully. We did a tasting prior to choosing our flavors and Alexis was so sweet and kind to work with. She captured our vision perfectly and we couldn’t have had a better experience. Can’t wait to return and buy some sweet treats in the future!

My sister brought peanut butter eggs and a carrot cake that Alexis made her for Easter. I’ve never heard of Heavenly Sweet Bakery but I think she is our new go to bakery! The carrot cake was to die for and the peanut butter eggs were out of this world! I would strongly recommend them for anyone looking for a custom cake, cupcakes, pies or any other bakery needs in the Dover or York, Pa area! Amazing!

Couldn't be happier with my experience(s) ordering from Heavenly Sweet Bakery. Everything we've tried has been delicious and Alexis absolutely nailed our wedding order. My now-husband and I loved our tasting (we did the take home option) and the cake and cupcakes we settled on for the big day were perfect. Definitely would recommend!

We LOVE to get desserts from Alexis but she seriously out did herself this time ☺️ We ordered cupcakes for my mom’s surprise 50th and they were (seriously) some of the best cupcakes I’ve ever had. We ordered chocolate cake with peanut butter icing and lemon cake with raspberry filling—both AMAZING. Everyone raved about them and she matched our design inspiration exactly!! The perfect sweet treat for a sweet surprise for my mom. Thank you!!

I can't believe I have not yet made a review on google ! Alexis does such amazing work and is wonderful to work with. We ordered a cake for our wedding in September 2023 and it was beautiful, our guests would not stop raving about it. We chose a pink champagne cake, raspberry filling, and white chocolate buttercream frosting. We only got one bite during the wedding, so after the wedding we ordered a dozen cupcakes. YUM! The process of ordering for our wedding was super easy. We chose flavors we were interested in and sat down for a tasting, it probably took 15 minutes and we had our cake ordered! She delivered on day of and everything was beautiful. We go here for all of our baked good needs, she does such amazing work. Thank you, Alexis!