Island Creek Oyster Retail Shop

Got 50 oysters for NYE and they were fantastic! And got some caviar & shrimp cocktail. We also appreciated them providing us crushed ice for serving when we asked! We will definitely be back!

This was at one point a 5 star review but has dropped to 3 star for small size, price and lack of quality service. I never write bad reviews but after dropping $200 on tiny oysters I’m not a happy camper. I have supported ICO for years buying quality products w great service. That was not the experience I had today. I’ll post pics once I find a tiny knife to open tiny shells

First time here and was passing through. They had some delicious Island Creek oysters for $1.75 each.

I'm no oyster expert, but I've had these multiple times and they are always delicious. I think it's also pretty great deal considering the high quality product you're getting.

I bought two bags of oysters. One bag was sweet and succulent. The other bag had dead and dry oysters in it. First time this has happened. For the money spent, it was a disappointing value.