Greco's Italian Ices And Homemade Ice Cream

OMG, so good! It's tucked back off the street. Invisible. We were wondering why they don't have big signs pointing people their way. I guess they don't need to - the ice cream is just that good! And huge portions too. But most importantly, really delicious ice cream using local ingredients. Love it!

They’ve got vegan options, which are of course dairy free as well, and all of the ice cream is homemade. The staff was very friendly and helped us learn about other attractions in the area as well. It was delicious!

One of the hidden gems in lititz. Ice cream, Italian Ice, you name it. If its a sweet treat they will make it!

Walked in with my cousin who lives in the area. I briefly viewed the menu saw Reese’s ice cream as an option and requested a Reese’s milkshake but with vanilla ice cream if they use chocolate as its base. The young lady helping us replied oh yea you can change it to how you like. Cool. My cousin ordered mint chocolate chip milk shake. I went to the car with my toddler while my cousin waited. When she got in the car and handed me my milk shake it was all white and I said this looks like a vanilla milk shake indeed it was. So I go back in. I was able to speak to the other young lady working out of the two and explain to her that I asked for a Reese’s milk shake and got vanilla. I was then told they don’t offer Reese’s milk shakes, it’s not even on the menu so she wasn’t sure how this happen

We went there for the ice cream crawl and fell in love. The owner is super nice and welcoming and all the 50 flavors we tried we so good! My favorite is Pot luck. We will be back for sure.